Sadhvi Ritambhara is a Brown girl I discover unsettling and offensive.
However as a result of she’s not an undocumented laborer “stealing” a working-class job or condemning Israel’s bombing of Palestinians, she won’t scare off xenophobes and patronizing liberals deft at accommodating informal anti-Muslim and anti-Arab bigotry.
Ritambhara, an Indian, really does have so much in frequent with many U.S. residents, together with some elected leaders and a handful of my Fb “associates” who’ve brazenly disparaged Muslims, but nonetheless handle to be characterised pretty much as good, considerate folks.
What units Ritambhara aside is that her best hits of Islamophobic rants have been recorded and bought on cassettes, inspiring Hindu nationalist mobs to demolish a sixteenth century mosque in northern India and the lethal communal riots that adopted over three many years in the past.
Ritambhara, who was scheduled to look on the Hanuman Temple of Better Chicago in Glenview this weekend, as soon as likened Muslims to lemons in milk, inflicting the milk — a metaphor for India — to curdle.
She additionally reportedly in contrast Muslims to flies on a mass-breeding mission to surpass India’s Hindu inhabitants, which at present hovers round 1.1 billion out of 1.4 billion.
Ritambhara, 61, has used her verbal venom to smear India’s Christians, too. However she’s finest recognized for her previous hate speeches concentrating on Muslims. These classic pep talks, which “masterfully mix spiritual imagery with emotional appeals” have helped normalize brutality in an India that’s veering away from a secular democracy, mentioned Kalyani Menon, a non secular research professor at DePaul College.
“Airing contentious views shouldn’t be the issue,” mentioned Menon, whose scholarly work examines up to date spiritual politics in India. Nevertheless, “Phrases that may justify or incite violence towards explicit teams is regarding,” he mentioned.
I emailed and rang a quantity that was on a flyer showcasing Saturday’s occasion on the Hanuman Temple’s Instagram web page to verify whether or not officers have been contemplating a request made by almost 100 people and organizations to rescind Ritambhara’s invitation. As of Friday, I hadn’t heard again.
Giving Ritambhara a plaform in a Hindu temple is “an affront and insult to us as Hindus as a result of what she represents is antithetical to the Hindu teachings of affection, compassion and tolerance,” mentioned Pranay Somayajula, director of organizing and advocacy for the Hindus for Human Rights’ nationwide workplace in Washington, D.C.
Different teams who joined Hindus for Human Rights in urging the north suburban temple to uninvite Ritambhara, included SACRED — the South Asian American Coalition to Renew Democracy — and the Muslim Civic Coalition.
Since her arrest for inciting violence as town of Ayodhya’s pied piper, Ritambhara has softened her picture as a cuddly elder sister and maternal “Didi Maa” who uplifts underprivileged girls and youngsters.
This misleading glow-up is why “many within the Hindu diaspora are unaware of her political lineage, revering her as they might any Hindu ascetic,” Menon mentioned.
Up to now, spiritual facilities in different elements of the U.S. and United Kingdom canceled Ritambhara’s deliberate appearances as soon as they have been knowledgeable of her notoriety. Others, conscious of her historical past, unabashedly embrace her troubling ideology.
Ritambhara has by no means apologized for her incendiary remarks and function within the destruction of Babri Masjid, which she and others on the Hindu proper claimed stood on the website of a temple marking the birthplace of Lord Ram, a revered Hindu deity.
Not solely have been she and 31 others acquitted for the flattening of the mosque by a judiciary sympathetic to India’s right-wing extremists in 2020, Ritambhara was awarded, in January, with the Padma Bhushan, one in every of India’s highest civilian honors.
The “spiritual saint,” as Ritambhara was referred to as by the Hindustan Instances, cried final yr on the inauguration ceremony of the grand Ram Temple earlier than an exuberant crowd teeming with Bollywood stars.
Many Indians of various faiths right here and overseas haven’t forgotten the tears they shed after they noticed the Babri Masjid crumbling on the identical spot in 1992.
“No quantity of disinformation or variety of awards can change” Ritambhara’s ungodly legacy, mentioned Pushkar Sharma, co-founder and government director of SACRED, which was based in 2024 to beat hate within the South Asian America group in Illinois.
I flew into India a couple of days after the Babri Masjid was toppled. Fortunately, my dad and mom’ residence state of Bihar was spared from the following bloodshed. However the worry and pressure have been palpable.
My cousins begged me to not convey up the leveling of the mosque and rising anti-Muslim sentiment in public. An uncle recommended some Hindu names to make use of if I encountered police.
The hate propelled by Ritambhara’s diatribes has solely gotten stronger as India retains nosediving additional into fascism.
By the point this column runs in print, Ritambhara is likely to be digging right into a black bean burger at Hackney’s on Harms, basking in a post-speech glow.
Or she may have been run out of city.
However wherever she is throughout her newest American tour, I doubt she’ll be disappeared or taken into custody for her despicable worldview. If solely others who by no means triggered hurt have been so fortunate.
Rummana Hussain is a columnist and leads the opinion protection on the Solar-Instances.
Wish to write a letter to the editor or an op-ed? Take a look at our tips.
Get Opinions content material delivered to your inbox. Join our weekly publication right here.
